Posted by: taylorjs | February 5, 2010

Orlando Hudson in, Casilla Gone?

I don’t have much to add to the notes of praise about the Twins Orlando Hudson signing yesterday.  The Twins are clearly better today than they were yesterday, when Nick Punto was the most likely starting second baseman.  I’ll save my thoughts on Punto for February 12 (might as well join in the Nick Punto Day fun, after all), but it’s pretty clear that slotting a guy with a 779 career OPS is a massive upgrade over a guy with a 646 career OPS.

The question is who will come off the roster to make room for Hudson.  To me, there is only one answer — it has to be Alexi Casilla.  At this point, even if the Twins still hoped that Casilla could be a longer-term solution to the problem, they’d face the difficulty of having nowhere to stash him in 2010 (because he’s out of options) and nowhere to play him in 2010 (because of Hudson).  They certainly can’t afford to burn a roster spot on him for no purpose other than being a backup to a guy who is expected to play every day.

We should find out soon what the Twins decide to do — but if they waive another young player and lose him, only to have to get rid of Casilla anyway when Spring Training is over, would be a waste.  The only reason to do this would be to hope that a trade could be worked out at the end of Spring Training — but the player received in the deal would have to be better than the player removed from the 40-man roster now (assuming that player was lost) to make that work, and that seems awfully speculative unless the Twins have already secured a buyer.  It was a bit of a strange ride, Alexi — but the time has come to part ways.  I’m hoping the Twins see it the same way.



  1. I concur!

  2. Tolbert would be my preference. Not that there’s much difference in value. Tolbert can probabaly play more positions, but Casilla can play better up the middle. Both are superfluous with Harris and Punto already on the roster.

  3. The difference between Tolbert and Casilla is that Tolbert has options remaining while Casilla does not. If the Twins were to waive Tolbert now, they would still end up having to waive Casilla at the end of Spring Training (barring something unforeseen like Casilla winning a job). Get rid of Casilla now, and Tolbert can still be sent to AAA in April. I see no reason to risk losing two players when one will suffice. It would be poor roster management in my opinion.

  4. Good point, I should have checked on that first. You’re right. And with Hardy/Punto/Harris/Hudson, there’s no chance Casilla wins a spot this spring.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: